Sutton Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Sutton, Vermont—a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque landscapes of Caledonia County. This charming town is known for its serene beauty, friendly community, and an abundance of outdoor recreational opportunities. Whether you're an avid hiker, a winter sports enthusiast, or someone who simply appreciates the tranquility of nature, Sutton offers a lifestyle that many dream of.

One of the most attractive features of Sutton is its diverse real estate market, particularly for those seeking homes under $500,000. Here, you can find a variety of properties that cater to different tastes and lifestyles. From cozy cabins surrounded by lush woodlands to charming single-family homes with stunning mountain views, Sutton has something for everyone. These affordable housing options make it an ideal location for first-time home buyers, families, and retirees alike.

Living in Sutton means embracing a slower-paced lifestyle while still being close to modern conveniences. The town is just a short drive from bustling local shops, delightful eateries, and essential services, ensuring that you have everything you need within reach. Plus, with its strong sense of community, you’ll quickly feel at home among friendly neighbors and local events.

If you're looking for a place where natural beauty meets affordability, Sutton, VT is the perfect choice. Discover your dream home in this idyllic town and experience the enchanting lifestyle that awaits you!

Newest Sutton Homes under $500,000

$289,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5110577 MLS

Bean Pond is practically at your doorstep! Built in 2023 and set on 5 acres in Sutton, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath manufactured home combines the ease of a newer home with a setting made for enjoying Vermont. Take in views of Bean Pond and the surrounding hills right from the living room and expansive front deck, then simply cross the road to the Vermont Fish & Wildlife fishing and boating access. With the driveway located directly across from the access, getting a kayak, canoe, or boat on the water couldn’t be much easier. Inside, the open floor plan connects the living, dining, and kitchen spaces, with large windows keeping the pond and hillside views front and center. The kitchen features a large center island, abundant cabinetry and counter space, stainless steel appliances, tile backsplash, and range hood. The primary suite offers a spacious bedroom, walk-in closet, and private bath with double vanity. Two additional bedrooms, a second full bath, and dedicated laundry room complete the convenient one-level layout. Outside, the mostly wooded 5-acre parcel offers privacy along with usable lawn surrounding the home, a fire pit area, and plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors. A separate cleared and level area on the property includes an existing pole barn providing covered storage with additional room for equipment and recreation. The home was placed here in 2023 along with a new septic system, followed by a drilled well in 2024, making this an opportunity where much of the work of establishing the property has already been done. Whether you’re looking for a year-round home or a Vermont getaway, this one puts acreage, water access, beautiful views, and four-season recreation all within reach.

6655 Us Route 5, Sutton

$480,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5108297 MLS

The quiet hills of Sutton Vermont hide a gem near phenomenal lakes & fishing, skiing, mountain biking, and Snowmobiling… A wonderful home or even a B & B opportunity exists in this large, comfortable Post & Beam house with spacious radiant addition & loft! The placid pond greets you on your drive up to this 4 bedroom home on 6 acres. The scent from the apple orchard with 40+ trees with the glimpse of mountains on the horizon as you step around the corner, is blissful on a sunny day. A major renovation by the long time owners has just been completed. Beautiful! It began in 2021 with a complete basement replacement & basement addition totaling 1,584 sq. ft. of heated space, all with new perimeter drains. The 24 X 24 ft addition with cathedral ceiling stands 2 stories tall with a loft & exterior upper balcony. The entire house was completed with all New plumbing, Roofing & Siding, Electrical revamp, new flooring throughout, windows, baseboard Heating system, a cozy pellet fireplace, and Radiant heat for the addition. Even a cement pad for B-ball or use it for a 2 car garage. Turn-Key and ready for the Good Life!

1148 Wheelock Rd, Sutton

$389,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5107568 MLS

This fully and lovingly renovated farmhouse is ready for its next chapter. This property has had extensive updates and improvements, while still maintaining the charm and features of a classic Vermont home. The large inviting kitchen features natural wood and stone accents, new appliances, along with a walk-in pantry with laundry hook up. Wood accents continue throughout the home, leading to a spacious living room, made cozy and warm by a pellet stove and hardwood floors. The first level includes an updated full bath, with a new tile shower and custom built in shelving. The second floor features a large primary bedroom, expanded to allow for incredible natural light, vaulted ceilings with decorative exposed beams, and generous closet space. Second floor also includes 2 additional bedrooms, and a remodeled 3/4 bath with tile shower. This home sits on a 2 acre lot, with open lawn space, fruit trees, running brook, and outdoor entertaining space on the porch and fire pit area. The 24'x40' garage is ready for your vehicles and equipment, fully insulated and heated, with 13’ raised ceiling and 10’ garage door, workbench, cabinets and upstairs storage space. Off the back side of the garage is a new 12'x36' overhang for even more covered storage for tools and equipment. The possibilities are endless and exciting with this turn-key home. This property also includes a 2.31 acre lot on Route 5A, this additional land is partial wetland, not suitable for a homesite but possible lot for a camper/tiny house/camp, or storage. Land is MLS listing #5075573

135 E Ridge Rd, Sutton

$129,000

5 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5104752 MLS

Built in 1841 this classic Vermont farmhouse is situated on a 0.52 acre corner lot in the heart of Sutton. Full of original character and ready for its next chapter, this property offers spacious rooms, exposed wood beams, wide plank floors and brick chimneys. Surrounded by farms and historic village homes, yet still within reach of some of the North East Kingdom's greatest attractions and recreational opportunities. Bring your ideas and picture the possibilities! Property will likely not qualify for low down payment financing options.

15 Burke Rd, Sutton

$399,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5102615 MLS

155 ACRES + 2,184 SF LOG HOME NOW $399,000 A rare opportunity to own 155 private Vermont acres with a substantial 2003 log home, sweeping views and a waterfall. The structure is in place, with electric, septic, well, metal roof, two-car garage and radiant-floor infrastructure. The interior remains unfinished, offering an opportunity for the buyer to complete the kitchen, bathrooms, flooring and heating system according to their own specifications.

6791 Us Route 5, Sutton

$289,000

5097180 MLS

This versatile home offers spacious living quarters on the upper level with an eat-in kitchen, large living room/dining room, 3 bedrooms, a full bath, and a laundry room. The lower level offers a 3 room apartment ideal for elderly parents, grown children or other family members, or to use for a short or long term rental. It also could provide a location for an in home business such as a beauty parlor, professional office, or similar type of home occupation. There is additional space on the lower level for a workshop or garage. The spacious back and side yards are ideal for a garden space, a play area for kids and for gatherings with family and friends. You have a babbling brook on one side of the house and a larger stream (Calendar Brook) just across the road. The property has frontage on both, and the house did not receive any damage from the flooding in the past couple years. The hard work has been done with a recently installed boiler, well pump and roof. Come check out this versatile opportunity.

2214 Calendar Brook Rd, Sutton

$289,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5097137 MLS

2214 Calendar Brook Rd, Sutton

$315,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5095095 MLS

Sitting on 45.1 acres, this off grid log home offers the perfect blend of comfort and self sufficiency. Designed and used as a primary residence, 3 bedrooms and a bathroom powered by solar with a generator backup, heated with both propane and wood, making it efficient and dependable in every season. The property features open meadows, wooded acreage, and apple trees providing a mix of recreation, natural beauty, and homestead potential. A barn and shed offer space for animals, equipment, or hobbies while the land spans both sides of the road for added privacy and flexibility. Sitting beside the Wiloughby State Forest and close to the VAST Trails ideal for snow mobiles, hiking, hunting, and exploring nature right out your front door.

4948 Underpass Rd, Sutton

$449,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5092928 MLS

When we say move in ready and a perfect home, we mean it! As perfect of a home that you will find! With 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths this home comes with 7.08 private acres. There is a direct entry, attached, two car garage with beautiful storage above. There is nothing to do here but move in and live! As you enter the home you will find an entry area with closets and laundry. Move in to the modern kitchen that flows into the dining room with wood floors that continues into the living room. A first floor bedroom and full bath round out the main floor. Upstairs you will find two large bedrooms and the second full bath. The basement is full, dry and very usable. There is a bulkhead to the outside. The utilities are updated with an oil fired, hot water furnace that makes the domestic water. It's just a nice basement. There is a brand new septic installed this year so no need to worry about that. The roof has been replaced. The land that this home sits on is slightly sloping, with the home a distance from the paved road. It's only a few minutes into town for everything that's important. This home really does have it all!

3172 Calendar Brook Rd, Sutton

$79,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5092167 MLS

This charming 2 acre lot features a well placed housesite well back from the sleepy country road surrounded by open lawn and field on all sides. The older double wide mobile home on the site has been lived in year round and can still be utilized in that fashion. The house features a nice sized kitchen with separate dining area, living room with woodstove, shared full bath, primary bedroom with attached half bath, and 2 additonal bedrooms. It does have some deferred maintenance and is being sold "as-is". The home has a few soft spots in the floors that will need to be fixed. Attached to the home is an enclosed porch and 2 car garage. Fix up the home and have your own place for far less than the cost of an apartment, or remove the house and build a new one in its place. Water, septic and power are all in place and could be used for a new home.

1760 Wheelock Rd, Sutton

Start Your Search

board logo Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated .